by Timothy Bartik & Kathleen Bolter, W.E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research
Within the economic development field, the scarcest resource may soon not be suitable land or skilled labor or essential building materials. It may be the public’s trust.
Across the country, communities are watching large projects being promised accompanied by tax incentives, infrastructure commitments and promises of jobs. However, alongside these investments, Americans’ dissatisfaction with the size and influence of major corporations has reached a record high. In Gallup’s 2026 polling, 49% of Americans said they were “very dissatisfied” with the size and influence of major corporations.
That trust gap is increasingly visible in community debates over data centers, clean energy projects and other major developments.
That should concern anyone involved in site selection.
When communities become skeptical of a proposed development, the traditional response is often to strengthen the communications effort by working to better explain the project, quantify the investment and publicize the jobs that will be created. While those things definitely matter, communications alone cannot solve a low-trust environment.
Rather, trust itself has to be built into the economic development strategy by giving local residents a credible stake in the overall outcome.
Our recent work in Chattanooga, Tennessee, points toward how economic developers and businesses might do that.
A Credible Path
In our latest study, we look at what might happen if the City of Chattanooga paired workforce training with its Payment in Lieu of Taxes agreements, or PILOTs. The city’s PILOT agreements already reduce property taxes for companies that invest and create jobs. We modeled what could happen if those deals were paired with a deliberate workforce strategy that combines customized training, apprenticeships and job-focused certificate and associate degree programs through community colleges.
For site selectors, the question can no longer end with whether a project will create jobs and investment.
The goal of this pairing is not just to attract investment, but to increase the likelihood that local residents share in its benefits. If taxpayers are helping to support a project, the residents in the community should have a credible path to the jobs and earnings that project is expected to create.
The estimated impacts of pairing incentives with workforce development are striking. Across seven industries we examined, the average city PILOT alone costs about $10,140 per job and produces an estimated 88 cents in benefits to Chattanooga residents for every dollar spent. Combine those incentives with targeted training, however, and the estimated return rises to $5.24 per dollar, producing roughly $51,500 in net benefits per job over 20 years. Considered on its own, the additional investment in training produces more than $25 in resident benefits for every additional dollar spent.
If we include the effects on state revenue as well as local revenue, we estimate that adding training to the economic development package produces fiscal benefits that exceed the costs of the training. The ratio of state and local fiscal benefits to the extra training costs is $3.49 in fiscal benefits per $1 in training costs.
In other words, pairing incentives with workforce development changes the economics of the deal dramatically.
Why is there such a large difference? In part, because high-quality targeted training programs are cost-effective in inducing business location decisions and hence creating local jobs.
But adding training also pays off because attracting a job and improving the economic circumstances of existing residents are not necessarily the same thing.
When new jobs are created, there is no guarantee that local residents will fill them. In many instances these positions are filled by workers relocating from elsewhere. Targeted training changes this equation by helping local residents compete for the positions the economic development policy helped create in the first place. The important caveat is that the success of such efforts depends on the quality of the training itself. To be successful, training must be closely aligned with employers’ hiring needs.
Creating an explicit connection between investment and local opportunity matters for more than just the greater economic return. It also shapes whether or not residents see a credible path connecting a publicly supported project to opportunity for people who already live there.
Our analysis finds the gains of this strategy are not concentrated at the top. We find that lower- and moderate-income Chattanooga residents stand to see the largest increases in earnings relative to their incomes. For workers who are unemployed, underemployed or otherwise on the margins of the labor market, access to the right training can make the difference between watching new jobs arrive and actually being employed in them. Pairing incentives with workforce development therefore does more than improve the overall return on public investment; it helps spread the benefits of economic growth more broadly across the community.
For site selectors, the question can no longer end with whether a project will create jobs and investment. It must also include whether the people who already live in the community have a credible opportunity to share in those gains.
Trust is not a message to be delivered after a project is announced. It is an outcome that has to be earned. And one way to earn it is to build it into the economic development deal itself through credible pathways into the jobs being created and measurable benefits for local workers and families. Ultimately, the public needs to be able to see, in concrete terms, how the project is delivering for the community.

Timothy Bartik is a senior economist at the W.E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.

Kathleen Bolter is principal (project lead) for Policies for Place, W.E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.
The full Chattanooga report is available at research.upjohn.org/up_technicalreports/. The report’s co-authors were Bartik, Iryna Lendel and Sevrin Williams.