Skip to main content

Online Insider

The Person Before the Place

Photo by Kobus Louw: Getty Images

How the first leadership hire quietly decides where foreign companies land.

By Olivier Safir

When a foreign company tells me it is coming to the United States, the first serious conversation is rarely about a state, a tax credit or a building. It is about a person. Should headquarters send one of its own to run the operation, or should it hire an American?

Most boards treat that as an HR matter to settle after the location is chosen. In practice it is one of the earliest site selection decisions the company makes — whether or not anyone calls it that — and it often narrows the map before a consultant has drawn up a long list.

Two Maps, Drawn by Two Different People
Take the case where headquarters plans to send a trusted manager. The location search starts to bend, sometimes without anyone saying so, toward places where that person and their family can settle: a direct flight home, an international school, a community from their country, a time zone that does not put every call with headquarters at midnight. A region can look ideal on labor costs and incentives and still lose because the expatriate’s spouse cannot see a life there.

Now take the case where the company intends to hire a U.S. executive. The question becomes where the right leaders already live or would agree to move. Experienced plant managers, country heads and quality leaders cluster in certain regions and industries. Put a site far from those pools and the first senior hire becomes slower and more expensive. Every later hire depends on that one.

These are genuinely different maps. I have seen boards approve a site on the first logic and then decide, a year later, to hire locally. That is how a company ends up searching for a leader in a place that leaders were never likely to choose …

Take a German industrial-automation company that shortlisted a Midwestern site around an expatriate director’s family needs. Our consultants approach it by asking, before the incentive package is signed, where experienced U.S. plant and commercial leaders in that sector already live, testing whether they would move to the shortlisted town, and only then confirming the location. When the answer is no, we widen the map rather than force a hire into a place leaders will not choose.

Why the Expatriate Option is Attractive, and Where It Runs Out
The case for sending someone from home is strongest in the first year. They know the product, the people who make decisions and the standards that have to be transferred. A board committing serious capital far away wants someone it trusts on the ground, and that trust has real value during start-up.

The limits show up later and more quietly. U.S. employment law, unfamiliar regulators and building a local team all take time to learn. American managers judge quickly whether the person they would report to understands their market and their careers. And assignments end. If no American successor has been developed by then, the company faces the leadership question again, this time with a running plant at stake and, often, in a location chosen for someone who is leaving.

The Local Hire Comes With Its Own Questions
A U.S. executive brings market knowledge, a network and credibility with local officials, partners and employees. But strong candidates are cautious about foreign-owned operations.

They ask early and directly: “Who do I report to, and what can I decide on my own?” A vague answer costs the company its best candidates. Pay is the other common stumbling block. Offers built on home-country salary scales, without the bonus and long-term incentives American executives expect, tend to fail at the last step.

Many of the companies I see do well end up with some combination: an American who owns local decisions, and a manager from headquarters who protects standards and keeps the parent informed. That arrangement has its own location test: attractive enough to recruit the American and their team, and livable enough for the expatriate and their family.

Being a JD/MBA by education helps me press for that clarity in writing. My company started in the late ’80s and I took it over in 2006, so I have seen so much transformation with startups and Fortune 500s appointing managerial teams, senior executives, CEOs or Board members… and the pattern holds across both. Having interviewed thousands of candidates from all across the world, I get empirical data, like metadata if you will: Neither an expat-only plan nor a late local hire works when the map was drawn without them.

What This Means for Economic Developers
For economic development organizations and site consultants, there is a practical opportunity here. Most foreign investors arrive with a business case and a rough geography. Far fewer arrive with an answer to who will lead the operation in its first year and its third. Asking that question early, before the short list, can save months.

The communities that stand out can speak to it with evidence: where experienced leaders in the relevant industry already work, which flights and schools serve relocating families, how spouses find work, and how other foreign-owned employers in the region have staffed their senior roles.

Incentives alone cannot do that.

Companies that settle the leadership question first tend to choose their location with more confidence and build their U.S. teams faster. The building, the permits and the incentive package all matter. Nonetheless, the person who will run the place usually decides whether it works, and it pays to think about that person before the map is drawn.


Olivier Safir is CEO of Pact & Partners, where he leads global executive searches, helping foreign companies hire leaders in the United States.